This is my theory as well. They are probably on a beach somewhere relaxing with drinks (and matching wedding bands, pink of course) in their hands.

If they did break up, did JLO give back the rock? Probably not.

the first thing I thought of when I read this was the vid w/ Michael Jackson and Lisa Marie Presley walking around nekkid. bleeeeccccccchhhh. thanks a lot, smiley. ;)

I feel the same way. I think, and this is totally MY speculation, but that maybe the relationship started out as infatuation for both, then they tried to force a significant relationship out of it. I kinda thought something was fishy about their relationship when they started giving each other large expensive gifts. To me that made the realtionship seem superficial.

You all gossip too much.

That is all.


-10 points for everyone

It's not gossip. We are discussing current events. The 'Bennifer' story may not have an impact on the strength of the Euro against the Yen or settle peace in nations at war now, but if it is in 'People' magazine or on 'Access Hollywood' it is a newsworthy event that must be discussed. ;)

That wouldn't explain why they are currently in separate cities.

Besides, if they wanted the press to stop following them, they wouldn't have faked a break-up -- I'm sure that they know that the press will be tailing them for weeks now in order to catch their "rebound relationships" with random models and singers and actors a la Britney and Justin.

Supposedly, Ben was already seen making out with some British singer "friend" of his backstage at the Tonight Show .

I think that Ben should be seen making out with ME. ;)

I think you have to wait in line. ;)
But first we have to clean the "J Lo" off of him! :p

I don't know what her deal is-
she was really cute and then dated P Diddy and she became J hoe.... I mean seriously, she lost half her name and most of her clothes too!

As for Ben- here;s the story, so Matt Damon was at Derby two years ago and I was there and he had pictures from it and last week he and Matt were hanging out and Ben saw that pic. So of course he falls in love and tells matt he has to dump that big ole booty for some KY lovin!
He wants a southern girl not some freaking snotty brat... that's still Jenny from the block!

I swear, I thought the thread was "Ben and Jerry are ka-put" and THAT really WAS a tragedy!!!

I herd Ben's mom was the cause to the death of their engagement.

I would not be surprised.........

i don't buy the breakup.

i think it's their version of throwing off the press while they secretly get married

Well seeing as he is older than I am, no his mother was not the reason for their break up... i am... i will claim full responsibility.