![]() |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I was in college when auxiliary groups were banned, and there was definite concern on the part of NPC groups (maybe fraternities as well, I don't remember that) that allowing them to continue could jeopardize the single-sex status of both fraternities and sororities. There may have been other factors as well, but that is the reason that we were given.
|
FOUND IT!
The resolution, passed in 1990, is not as specific as I originally thought - the only mention it makes of reasons for abolishing them is: Quote:
|
I still want to know who is collecting this data, and what it is going to be used for as it wasn't on the survey monkey page. Four classes on research methods in college makes me want to know who is wanting my opinion, under what authority, and why. I couldn't find a PI to contact if I had questions and that is a concern for me.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
It still comes down to membership selection, and as well all know that MS is private the issues and discussion (if any) will likely be handled there. |
In response to some of the other questions that have been posed...
If there were no legal repercussions: 1) Would I be willing to accept a transgendered aspirant (physically male/identifies as a woman): YES 2) Would I be willing to accept a transsexual aspirant (born male/reassignment surgery/identifies as a woman): YES 3) Would I be willing to accept a transgendered aspirant (physically female/identifies as a man): Probably not - If you identify as a man, I'd need a really good reason why you want to join a women's organization. 4) Would I be willing to accept a transsexual aspirant (born female/reassignment surgery/identifies as a man): Same as #3 5) Would I recognized a soror who was transsexual/transgendered, identifying as either a man or a woman: YES, without reservation. Theta Nu Xi specifically indicates that membership is open to women. Like I said, it wouldn't make sense to me that someone identifying as a man would want to join. We currently have members who consider themselves gender fluid and/or are trying to determine how they will ultimately identify. Gender - as well as other issues - is difficult to determine for many people because there aren't many choices. Either you're a woman or man. There isn't a whole lot else unless you want to endure the cruelty of the world and be your own person. I consider myself biologically female, but on the scale from man to woman - gender-wise - I dance on the middle line, mostly leaning toward being a woman. That's probably TMI for some folks who are uncomfortable with this topic. If so, blame it on the QNX. ;) |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Come to think of it, I believe several years ago, one of our chapters did have an aspirant who identified as a man. I don't know how far it went, but I do know he never joined. So, it's certainly not unheard of. |
Quote:
The research I conducted, and have decided to continue to conduct for the next couple of years, was as stated in my distribution letter a study designed to assess the attitudes of Greek Life towards Gender, and the participation of alternative lifestyles (in this case alternative gender classes) in Greek Life as component of participation in the student life polity. (This is what qualitative research calls an ethnography). The survey is only one method my research has utilized and the study as whole is objective, but in the realm of political sociology is attempting to expose power structures of the Greek Life system, and what could be a potential problem of inclusion/exclusion in politics. For anyone who is interested you can reference the 2007 District Court of Appeals case that upheld the College of Staten Island's refusal to recognize a fraternity on campus that was single-sex. Prior discussion on the matter ended with Title IX back in the 90s, but to those of you who think the matter is trivial I can point to that case as just one of many examples of how it is not, beginning as early as a 1985 California Law Review that would outline the constitutional claim of an individual denied access to a "College Social Organization" regardless of federal statutes like Title IX. There are also numerous "alternative" Greek organization that fall under neither NPC or NIC's umbrellas that are coed that have come as a backlash to exclusion. The point of the study is to provide the foundation for these kinds of discussions to take place, and to encourage the discussions to reach comprehensive policy status before the battle each chapter faces ends up in a courtroom like Alpha Epsilon Pi did in 2006... I can't wait for the research to be complete, and I'll gladly share the results with everyone who wants them when the study is conclusive. |
I also feel like its worth mentioning here that the comments made about individuals who go under a sex change are kind of irrelevant to my study, although very interesting as well!, since we're focusing on gender issues, which by the world health organization are defined by behavior, not physical state of being (which is sex). Of course whether or not thats a true definition is debatable, but accounted for in our survey.
Also, I should mention that my campus is very non-traditional. The current pledge class president is around 40 years old, and just now pledging to SAE, plus Greek Life membership doesn't end at 22- membership is for life so I think the matter is very relevant, especially in a society that is becoming increasingly genderless according to sociology literature. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:48 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.