America, are you EFFING KIDDING ME? David Archuletta? Oh my god.

Me too. Too much hype about the battle of the David's, I guess.

Since I'm against everything David A.......no 17 year old is THAT goofy.he acts like he's 12

lets go David C

Ditto. In fact, the week they decided who was in the final 24, I had written Syesha's name down as one of the girls I really liked. I think she'll still get a recording contract.. maybe it will end up a blessing for her! Look at Jennifer Hudson after all!

ETA: I could have done without the Fantasia performance though.

All Fantasia did in that performance is whine on stage!

I really liked David Cook's little preview things, much better that the others!

I am sooo going for David Cook!

Simon's face during that performance said EVERYTHING that I was thinking.

I liked Syesha, but I'm not surprised at the results. I think she'll be successful in Broadway. =] With that said, I hope that David Cook wins!

Thank GOD for my DVR. We fast forwarded after listening to it for about 10 seconds. What was that God-awful chicken-like dance? I've never been a huge Fantasia fan though. To me, she always tried too hard to sound like Macy Gray. :rolleyes:


I actually like David A. :o I know that's not a popular opinion here, but the kid has vocals. I'd be happy to see either David win, big fan of them both.

I didn't think it was too bad.

Yes! Simon had the same question mark floating over his head as I did!

Even though Tasia's singng was a mess... her performance and energy was good. Part of the reason she won during her season.. she was never afraid of the stage or taking a risk

I cannot be the only one who wants to punch David A. in the face. Seriously, get a grip kid.

Not that I'm condoning violence or anything, but you aren't the only one.

Yes -- Go Cook!!

Thank you! Not that I think he is terrible because he has a wonderful voice. Just to me, the type of songs he sing will not do well on radio. When he picks songs he picks slow songs my mom listens to. The one pop song he did was a mini train wreck. I see him more on Broadway then on radio. Plus his facial expressions kill me inside.

Honestly? I think Cook threw it. The way he complimented DA so heartily at the beginning, said as far as he's concerned the contest is over and now they're just having fun and he stepped back and applauded DA, he did it again at the very end, I think David C. is ready for a huge career but that he'd be just as happy not carrying the title of "American Idol". DA is the perfect little minion for the big AI machine to take, mold and spit out into the market. David Cook is by far my favorite as an artist and performer, but I really didn't think he won the night. But then, I don't really think he was trying to.