I wanted Tamyra to win too. Second, I wanted Chris to win, b/c I really liked his voice and his aura and air of confidence. The thrid person I would have picked was Ryan. I actually liked her voice too. I didn't care for most of the songs sung last night, so I'm basically judging by their voices and creativity.

And was Kelli the one that did "I will always love you"? I liked her too. If I could pick 4, she'd be 4th...or maybe she' be 3rd and Ryan would be 4th...

There is a wildcard for the judges
 

So those that didn't get picked, one of them still may have a chance. Did you see how the girl with all the moppy hair that did Whitney was acting when she wasn't picked? She didn't want anyone to hug her and she wouldn't clap. Come on girl, you made it farther than a lot and who knows what will happen. Don't be a sore loser!

Re: There is a wildcard for the judges
 

Yeah, she was a sore loser. I mean she was sitting at the top w/ Jim, and she didn't hug him. But Chris didn't get up and hug anyone either, although he was sitting on the bottom, and he clapped. I hope he gets the wildcard vote.

Did anyone catch this last night ?

best performances tonight were
Tamyra
Justin
Christina

um
 

Didn't Justin get kicked out or summin? Who got kicked out on the show about 3 shows ago?

If Justin is the mixed brotha with the curly hair, I want him to win!


QTE

Re: um
 

There were 2 Justins. The Justin I like is the bi-racial kid with the straw set. :p The 2nd Justin was kicked off for lying about his age. I am not talknig about Ejay, the one who works @ Six Flags.

American Idol
 

Hey I was wondering if any of you are watching american idol. If so what do you think of it. I hate that christina got the boot. I want Tamyra to win! But Kelly and Justin got a fan base like i don't know what. But either way tamyra, justin and christina will all be famous. My prediction: justin doing coke commercials:p

I was almost in tears when Christina got the boot. I think R.J. (I think that's his name) should have gotten voted off. He even knew he should've been the one to go. Christina just seems like she is so humble.

I want Tamyra to win as well. But I also have to give it to Kelly... that girl can saaaang. And Justin also has a beautiful voice.

Give christina a few months. i am sure that we will hear a cd. Or see her modeling in a magazine! You could tell that rj was feeling bad! He forgot the words in his song. I want it to come down to justin and tamyra. Niki is trying to be another pink. And we don't need that. pink is popular because she is an original:D :p

BOO America
 

I've been keeping up with this since day one!!

I was like :eek: and :mad: then just plain :( when Christina got booted. R.J. sucked sucked sucked. For once I agree with Simon when he said, "R.J. you're incredibly lucky". But if they're on this show AND you have made it this far...they are going to get some offers from SOMEBODY, trust.

I just hate it that Christina had to hear this while she's in the hospital!! But I know she's going places.

I want Tamyra to win but she's got some competition with Justin and Kelly (those two ain't going anywhere). I think Niki's gonna be next. She hasn't been on point in like, three weeks. Her or R.J...I just don't like him. He was too lucky this week!!

The gossip mill has been floating rumors that Christina may have been tipped off about the outcome and decided not to show up. I'm really not sure about that. But, what was wrong with the host on Tuesday night? He was Dogging Ryan like when he said "Ryan get ready to take my order" That was not called for

After lst night who knows who is going to go next. I would like to see Rj or niki go. Did anyone catch entertainment tonight on tuesday. The idols went to see the new movie xxx. They couldn't say anything to the press. But Justin and Samuel Jackson are cousins. It is smart that they kept it quiet. Because people would have said that the only reason he got this far is because of his cousin. hmmm:p

Boo-hiss!!!! :mad: RJ should have been gone a long time ago... :mad:

I liked Christina and think she can sing, but I agree w/ the judges thatshe needs to work on her voice. I think she needs a vocal coach to perfect her talent...Nevertheless, I'm sure we'll be seeing her again...

Christina'a illness
 

It was reported that stress of the show triggered an asthma attack for hristina. I hope she gets well because I know how awful an attack like an asthma attack can be.

I would like to see Tamyra win, too. Kristina looked a little ill like she was real fragile or something.

I hoped everyone watched tonight! Tamyra really showed why she should win this competition. She had paula abdul crying.. And Simon said it was one of the best telivised performances he has ever seen!!! Even if she doesn't win I know simon will at least try to sign her!!!:p

The final competition should have Tamyra versus Kelly because the others are not as stellar as those two. Justin has lost his luster to me. Before straw set man could sing but now he has gone to being blase.


Nikki and RJ especially RJ should have gotten the boot before Christina. This is really how I pictured they would be eliminated.

RJ
NIKKI
Justin
Christina
Kelly with Tamyra winning it all because the past couple of weeks she has really just left chills up/down my spine.

However, I do see RJ becoming a member of what ever new boy band is in the works. Nikki will do the rock thing. You notice how her son was there last night. I bet you if she is not booted tonight because her performance last night was awful, she sounded like a CAT SCREECHING :eek: then she will be next week. RJ played it safe last night but he still was ho hum.

I agree CT4. I think RJ and Nikki will be the next two to go. It's going to be between Tamyra and Kelly in the end...I can't really say who's going to win it yet because Kelly definitely can give Tamyra a run for her money.

I wasn't feeling Nikki at all last night, she sounded terrible! But I also think she will go on and do her rock thing.

ok who's next, surely not Tamyra
 

I'm really eager to know on the show tonight whose going to get booted....I just know it isn't Tymyra.

I am so upset!!! Nikki should have been gone, Simon was right when he said she reminded him of the "Wedding Singer." But RJ did have it coming after he slid by Christina unfairly last week.
Nikki is horrible, if she doesn't lose next week I am going to stop watching forever! I really hope Kelly or Tamyra win it all, even though Justin is such a cutey =)

I think Nikki should have went before RJ as well. Even though RJ doesn't have the strongest voice, I love his smile :D (he has beautiful teeth, has anyone else noticed???). But Nikki is definitely the next to go.

I also think it's going to boil to Kelli and Tamyra. I honestly don't know who will win between the two. They both have beautiful, strong voices. I wish Justin, Kelli, and Tamyra could all be the American Idol. I don't want to see either one of them go. :(

Byyyeee RJ
 

Well I wanted RJ to go last week. And yes, he does have a nice smile...but he needs to work on his voice a little bit. Hopefully now he can see what he needs to work on.

Ummm...Nikki was hella lucky this week. She has been in the bottom 2 or 3 for going on a month now. I think she'll be gone next week. She knows in order to stay in this, she better be THE BOMB but I think she'll still get booted anyway.

Sorry ya'll but I don't think Justin is all that. He's still in this because the masses of "teeny boppers" find him to to be cute and all...but I still say that it will be between Tamyra and Kelly because they have NEVER had to worry about votes. Those ladies have great voices.

RJ's finally gone...NIkki is next...

Justin is cute, but he cannot sing better than Kelly or Tamyra.

Judging based on singing alone, Tamyra should win, follwed by Kelly...But I don't know if America (hint, hint) wants her to be the "American Idol"...Other than that, she is pretty and talented and marketable. Kelly is too...I'd be cool if either of them won...(they're both going to get record deals anyway)...

How come I was still singing with tamyara on a "bad performance". Notice the respect simon gives her. He didn't bash her he just said prove it to me the second time around!!!

I still think Tamyra has the strongest voice...despite her performance of Patti's song last night. Plus, Feel the Fire is MY JAM and I think she did well with that.

Tamyra voice is the best. She's ready to go into the studio. A little production work and her album will be tight. The other two girls...Kelly and Nikki...sound like they're screaming and need some further voice training.

Justin....he has good stage presence and knows how to work the stage. However, PYT was not a good choice for him.

I called in and voted for Tamyra last night because I really think that she needs all the support she can get. I'm a little worried about how the vote will turn out because of her performance last night, but she has been the strongest all along.

:mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!
I cannot believe that Tamyra is gone before Justin and Nikki.

:mad: I can't believe this mess! Justin should've been the next to go. Aside from Kelly, Tamyra was one of the strongest voices up there. I was hot when they got rid of Christina, but this was really messed up!

OMG!!! nikki should've been gone ages ago!!!!! i thought tamyra was gonna take it. she was my favorite. what the hell were the people who voted for nikki thinking? ugh. . . . .

Ole boy Simon said on Regis and Kelly that he thought Kelly would win. He said she has this ole timey voice like Patsy Cline. Just maybe, he l is going to be correct.

:confused:

This is a hot mess. Nikki and Justin should've been next. The judges looked stunned. Tamyra will make it big. We all knew that "America" was not going to vote for a Black American Idol :o

What!!! What did I miss? I saw the performances last night but I was NOT expecting that Tamyra would get sent home!

STUPID RECRUITMENT EVENT! I can't wait to read the recap of tonight's show. I am stupefied!

I thought for sure it was Nikki's time to go!

:o It must have been Tamyra's extensions. I thought her hair was SO cool at first, (little puff ball on top of her head) and then I liked it when it was straight, but I thought it made her lose a little bit of her style.
But then last night she came out with long, non-unique hair, and I couldn't stand the reddish highlights that started halfway down her hair! So that must have had some effect, right? Voters? what do you think?;) :confused: :eek:

I don't know i am not as surprised as when christina got the boot. Don't get me wrong Tamyra was and still is my favorite! But Randy got it right "Tamyra you are so much bigger than American Idol". American Idol is to find a pop superstar. Tamyra will be better in gospel or r&b.. I can not wait to hear her cd. The sad part is that the remaining three idols will record a cd. Then the night the one wins it will be rushed into mass production. I guess i will be watching miss teen usa instead of the idols result show next week!
:p :p :p :p :p

lawd!
 

This was my face when they said Tamarya over Nikki:eek:

I was in shock. I know I was pulling for either Justin or Kelly to win, but I at least thought she would be in the final two.

I saw something on Extra! that there was a problem with the voting for A.I. but it isn't airing until tomorrow.


QTE

I was outraged when Tamyra was eliminated. :mad: Everyone was shocked. :eek: I believe even Nikki knew she was the one that should've been eliminated. :o

The only reason Nikki won is because there's a big scandal going on with the voting. It's been said that they've detected that people have been using computers, to cast at least 10,000 votes, at one time, from one phone. It was even said that these votes are mostly in favor of Nikki, and that's what's been keeping her afloat.

With Tamyra gone, it's obvious this show isn't about who's got the best voice. But then again, neither is real showbusiness or Britney Spears and J-Lo wouldn't have singing careers. Justin and Nikki aren't as vocally talented as Kelly or Tamyra, but they both have a gimmick going for them. It wouldn't surprise me if one of those two win the competition.

I guess the game done changed now. Those other three better have their acts as tight as possible. I thought the Justin would be the one to be voted out, but then again he has the cute boy image going for him.

*Boo* *Hiss*
 

I KNOW I was screaming at the T.V. last night, "This is some bullish!!" I just couldn't believe it, Tamyra is gone! I'm so sad, she was my favorite...but she represented beautifully and exited with a lot of class.

Simon is right, she is so much bigger than this...and she is from Atlanta so I know there will be some opportunities for her when she gets home. She will blow up if she gets with the right people.

I agree that obviously this isn't about who can sing, this is going to be about how many records will sell when whomever's album drops...Somebody can sell Nikki, somebody can sell Justin. It's about noteriety (hope that's close to the right spelling, lol) and the final three better be on point next week. I know Nikki is counting her blessings right about now.

I agree Cricket...one of those two will probably win. Sad, but possible.

she'll be the next Shania Twain but Tamyra be the next Aretha Franklin!

I know here there was a mishap with the phone numbers. For some reason, instead of calling to vote for the contestants, locals did not use the area code, but instead called a local number to some person that called the TV station. :rolleyes: :confused:


http://davidkelley.com/idol/index2.html

You will find the results of the poll...