GreekChat.com Forums

GreekChat.com Forums (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/index.php)
-   Greek Life (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/forumdisplay.php?f=24)
-   -   The Golden Rule (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/showthread.php?t=121505)

UGAalum94 08-23-2011 10:06 PM

I suspect it's not surprising that I agree in principle with most of what the OP says. We can quibble about the relative obnoxiousness of implying we're embarrassing our GLOs, but I think it pales in comparison with some of the unnecessary meanness that a lot of us have delivered at one point or another.

However, I think cyberbullying is a huge overstatement of what goes on here. I'm skeptical of the cyberbullying concept generally and think that it's getting way blown out of proportion when identified as a social problem.

ETA: as usual MC nails it.

shirley1929 08-23-2011 10:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VandalSquirrel (Post 2084026)
Now maybe it is because I haven't been having the best day that I'm responding thusly, but instead of a passive aggressive finger wagging thread, why not just call out the individuals who are sugar pops mean girls and you think are poor examples? Why make a thread that the majority find insulting and ridiculous, and therefore make yourself a target for the horrible behavior of all of us?

Do I think a lot of posters, both PNMs and their mamas need to get a grip and step away from GC? Obviously! However I find the whole intention of this thread exponentially more ridiculous and ludicrous than things that have allegedly been said. I'm not going to tell someone to go to Happy Pony Rainbow Land (get it right if you're going to mock it and us) I'm going to tell you that if you're this butt hurt over GC you want to call us out and throw some shade, perhaps you need to learn about the ignore function or log off from the internet for awhile.

Call individuals and their behavior out by name, or keep it to yourself. If that statement is going to hold in the recruitment forum for a certain mama, daughter, and what not when people get accusatory, it is good enough for the Greek Life forum.

Quote:

Originally Posted by MysticCat (Post 2084029)
All right. My $0.02, for what they're worth:

I think threads like this rarely have the desired effect. Even when motivated by a sincere desire to improve things, they tend to come across as patronizing and preachy. People do not usually respond positively to what can come across like pontification. So the result is that more often than not threads like this produce the opposite of the desired effect. This is a fairly foreseeable outcome.

I think that is particularly true when legitimate opinions are minimized. For example, to ask that someone with a differing opinion not be called a "sock-puppet" or "troll" diminishes the valid criticisms of real sock-puppets and trolls by dismissing those criticisms as "you just disagree with/don't like them."

I also think it is particularly true when someone suggests in any way that others aren't living up to the ideals of their fraternity or sorority. I learned that the hard way many years ago. Judgmental observations are rarely appreciated.

Yes, many here go overboard sometimes, me included I'm afraid. But sometimes the harshness is, if not polite, understandable. The actions of some posters have taught others not to take everything at face value, or to recognize signs that something isn't on the up-and-up.

No, it's not always pretty. But I tend to think these things have a way of working and evening themselves out, and the best way for that to happen is through dialogue -- challenging specific posts that one thinks are out of line and letting the community, with moderator assistance when necessary, police itself.

Passive-aggressive threads like this, on the other hand, fan the flames and become part of the problem.

I'm dead honest when I say, I appreciate what you both have to say here. You're right, I am being passive aggressive and maybe it's just because I don't have time to comment on every single thread and look more like the "cyber-police" as I've been called here. My point from the first is to have people just think about the whole picture (and how your - not you personally of course - post might be received) when posting. That's it. I was probably too wordy in the way that I said it. So maybe that's a better way of saying it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by UGAalum94 (Post 2084049)
I suspect it's not surprising that I agree in principle with most of what the OP says. We can quibble about the relative obnoxiousness of implying we're embarrassing our GLOs, but I think it pales in comparison with some of the unnecessary meanness that a lot of us have delivered at one point or another.

However, I think cyberbullying is a huge overstatement of what goes on here. I'm skeptical of the cyberbullying concept generally and think that it's getting way blown out of proportion when identified as a social problem.

ETA: as usual MC nails it.

Cyber-bullying is a big statement, but the idea of continually kicking and dogpile-ing on someone when they're down, from behind a unknown username is more hurtful. You're more likely to say more damaging things when you can remain anonymous. They still hurt. Again, I'm just asking people to think before posting...that's all.

Drolefille 08-23-2011 11:54 PM

LARGE FREAKING POSTS (PART 1)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2083805)
GreekChat is a wonderful place for learning about all sorts of GLO’s. I know that many of the “old timers” get tired of repetitive questions and ignorance, but I thought I’d offer up some food for thought:

And here's where you made your first mistake.

Quote:

We are dealing with 18-20 year old women, most who are moving away from home for the first time and going through yet another life transition through recruitment. Emotions and tensions run high.
No. Freaking. Way. REALLY? Damn. News to me!
Quote:

We’re also dealing with their mothers, most of whom are sane, NON heli-moms, but their emotions are running high as well. Both groups may not be stepping out with their best foot forward when the stumble upon GreekChat.
Adult women should know enough to step away from the keyboard if they're going to rant about how Alpha Beta Gamma is a chapter of TRAMPS who aren't good enough for their daughter anyway. Damn, that'd be a good thread.
Quote:

1) Please do not “out” someone or threaten to tank their rush because of something they say out of ignorance or frustration. A simple PM or message to “please edit your post” would suffice. After that, please step away from the keyboard.
What happens in your world: The meanies of GC pounce on the poor desperate PNM who is emotionally traumatized after high emotions lead to frustated sayings.

What happens more often: GCers tell PNMs to STFU and stop posting because it's really freaking obvious where they go to school and who they are after they said something really stupid in the first place like, "What are the ranks of the sororities at my school and how can a one handed saxophonist like me get into the best one?" And even then it's generally because they don't listen.

Quote:

2) Limit your QFP’s.
No.

Quote:

Sometimes it feels like that person is trying to be chased off the message board when every statement they make is QFPed.
So?
Quote:

Doesn’t exactly make for a welcoming “We’re so happy to hear your story and we’re rooting for you” environment.
Sorry, our job is to play cheerleader? Where's it say that? People who feel as such will express that, people who wish to quote a PNM's comments will do that. Life goes on.

Quote:

3) Yes, they need to slow down and read historical links, but sometimes they just aren’t thinking rationally.
Right so don't TELL them to think rationally, just pity party them and treat them like they're incapable.
Quote:

Since they have just found Greek Chat, they might assume we haven’t been around a long time. We have, but they don’t realize that at first.
Guess how they can tell? They read the little date by the posters' names. And when someone tells them to do a search, or helpful people like KSUViolet post LINKS for them. God we're so cruel, making them do tricky things like read and think. (Dear lord this post reads like the poor female teenagers can't possibly think straight due to their crazy emotions. Not sure why we even bother educating the poor dears, really.)

Quote:

4) If someone has a differing opinion than you, please do not refer to him/her as a Sockpuppet or Troll. Particularly if that person’s start date with GC is longer than this past week.
You don't understand the meaning of those words obviously. EW has been trolling for years, and the socks usually make it a few months (or longer) without being called out. People who don't post their affiliations and still try to give advice on GC get called out for good reason. Put up or shut up. That goes for you too. Grow some ovaries and post your words with your letters.

And if we have multiple socks that are still around and posting because they're chickenshits and can't bear to be snarky under their real names - or have tarnished their real names so terribly I suppose.

Quote:

That person might have actually been lurking for quite sometime and finally decided to speak up.
Don't care, if you troll or sock you troll or sock no matter how long you lurk. The two are not connected.

Quote:

Also, just because someone hasn’t mentioned their GLO by name, does not mean that they are not a member of one. It might just mean that they’re trying to be discreet.
That is not discretion, that's making an ass of themselves. If I walk up to you and start telling you how to make a million dollars but I won't show you my bank statements, will you trust me?

If you're claiming authority on recruitment matters, put up or shut up. And quite frankly if you're going to claim to be a sorority member at all, put up or shut up. We have no time for perps. Verify your letters with another GC member of your organization and move on.

5) Can we refrain from bashing people who decide to withdraw? BLAH BLAH BLAH [/quote]
People get bashed for withdrawing BEFORE PREF while in the same breath bitching about being dropped by the popular chapters.

Quote:

6) Furthermore, I’d like to contend that “dog piling” and generally being unkind to strangers is unbecoming of each of our GLO’s.
Fuck off. Seriously. Where the fuck do you think you get off telling me what my GLO cares about? HQs read GC, and if they have an issue with something I say they can tell me about it. You, however, can go and fuck yourself.


Quote:

In today’s society, I believe that kicking a person when they are down, on the internet, while hiding behind a username is pretty much the exact definition of “cyber-bullying”.
No, it's not. Learn something before you post bullshit.
Quote:

There have been tragic cases noted in the media. Please do not become one of the headlines.
And WHERE THE FUCK do you get off piggybacking on real tragedies to try and make your point here?
Quote:

I’m not in favor of unicorns-pooping-rainbows, but I AM in favor of being kind and remembering the golden rule when dealing with all humans.
You don't actually know what the "golden rule" is do you? Newsflash, I follow it. Odds are so does everyone here. We just expect people to be direct with us and tell us when we're being stupid rather than pretending things are cupcakes and rainbows.

By the way you're being stupid.

Quote:

I’m also not stupid enough to believe that I’m not about to get flamed right now.
And yet you posted.

Quote:

I also know someone is going to reply to this post defending something they said or did. I may or may not be speaking directly to you.
Stop being a fucking coward and be direct or take your ball and go home.

Quote:

And, I also know that someone will make a snark about me and my measly 85 posts. Just because I haven't said much, doesn't mean I don't have much to say.
WTF would I need to snark you for that? That would be weaksauce. The passive aggressive bullshit you try to post as a call for ~*~Kindness~*~ is all I really need.

Seriously, your post count has nothing to do with it, this is so very much a "Do you even go here?" moment. I mean, really? It took you this long to find out how big and mean we are and now your brilliant solution was this post? Think longer next time.

Drolefille 08-24-2011 12:15 AM

LARGE FREAKING POSTS (PART 2)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MysticCat (Post 2084029)
All right. My $0.02, for what they're worth:

I think threads like this rarely have the desired effect. Even when motivated by a sincere desire to improve things, they tend to come across as patronizing and preachy. People do not usually respond positively to what can come across like pontification. So the result is that more often than not threads like this produce the opposite of the desired effect. This is a fairly foreseeable outcome.

Agreed.

Quote:

I think that is particularly true when legitimate opinions are minimized. For example, to ask that someone with a differing opinion not be called a "sock-puppet" or "troll" diminishes the valid criticisms of real sock-puppets and trolls by dismissing those criticisms as "you just disagree with/don't like them."
True, although I don't actually see that happening here.

Quote:

I also think it is particularly true when someone suggests in any way that others aren't living up to the ideals of their fraternity or sorority. I learned that the hard way many years ago. Judgmental observations are rarely appreciated.
Yep

Quote:

Yes, many here go overboard sometimes, me included I'm afraid. But sometimes the harshness is, if not polite, understandable. The actions of some posters have taught others not to take everything at face value, or to recognize signs that something isn't on the up-and-up.
Yep.

Quote:

No, it's not always pretty. But I tend to think these things have a way of working and evening themselves out, and the best way for that to happen is through dialogue -- challenging specific posts that one thinks are out of line and letting the community, with moderator assistance when necessary, police itself.
Precisely, if one has an issue, the best way to impact it is to address it.
[/quote]
Quote:

Passive-aggressive threads like this, on the other hand, fan the flames and become part of the problem.
FLAME ON
http://i.imgur.com/63yng.jpg
Quote:

Originally Posted by VandalSquirrel (Post 2084026)
Now maybe it is because I haven't been having the best day that I'm responding thusly, but instead of a passive aggressive finger wagging thread, why not just call out the individuals who are sugar pops mean girls and you think are poor examples? Why make a thread that the majority find insulting and ridiculous, and therefore make yourself a target for the horrible behavior of all of us?

This. (although making her a target provided some entertainment)

Quote:

I'm going to tell you that if you're this butt hurt over GC you want to call us out and throw some shade, perhaps you need to learn about the ignore function or log off from the internet for awhile.
And this.

Quote:

Call individuals and their behavior out by name, or keep it to yourself. If that statement is going to hold in the recruitment forum for a certain mama, daughter, and what not when people get accusatory, it is good enough for the Greek Life forum.
But mostly this.
Quote:

Originally Posted by als463 (Post 2083986)
Is it wrong of me that I am really looking forward to your post? This whole time I was thinking, "Why hasn't Drolefille said anything?" I also looked forward to reading something from MC, KS, and DrPhil.

I'm flattered I suppose

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084070)
You're right, I am being passive aggressive

Yes.
Quote:

and maybe it's just because I don't have time to comment on every single thread and look more like the "cyber-police" as I've been called here.
No, I'm going with coward.

Quote:

Cyber-bullying is a big statement, but the idea of continually kicking and dogpile-ing on someone when they're down, from behind a unknown username is more hurtful. You're more likely to say more damaging things when you can remain anonymous.
Gee, thank you internet scientist. This is not news. So when I speak with my letters and my username I'm not really being anonymous. You don't need my legal name and address. You on the other hand, don't seem to think your letters are part of your identity, are posting anonymously on the same website and think preaching at us is ok? Hmmmmmm.
Quote:

They still hurt. Again, I'm just asking people to think before posting...that's all.
You're assuming we don't think. We do. We just disagree with you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by violetpretty (Post 2083859)
Is it dogpiling if you're the first one to snark?

God stop being so mean.

/no it isn't.

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2083860)
If you want to dig through my posts, I have actually out-ed my school on more than one occasion. I choose not to out my GLO only because I've recently had relatives going through recruitment and would like to not leave a giant internet footprint like we've mentioned here on this site before.

That doesn't even make sense. My cousin went through recruitment at Mizzou and suffered no ill effects due to my presence here because I didn't make a big deal about it or post her life story. Your inability to do the same seems odd.

Quote:

I just know what it's like to be 18 and feeling like you're being ganged up on for something you've said. Cyber-bullying is real and much of it is in the perception of the receiver.
No, it isn't. And the posts in these threads aren't bullying.

Quote:

I'm just asking everyone to think before they say something that might be construed as bashing to a young adult. If that makes me a horrible person, please let me know. I think this site is a wonderful resource and just would like to see it a little more welcoming to noobs. That's all.
You're being really dumb right now. Maybe you're not all the time, I don't really have an impression of you outside of this thread, but right now... DUMB.

That's all.

knight_shadow 08-24-2011 12:36 AM

I don't think you covered everything, DF ;)

DrPhil 08-24-2011 12:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MysticCat (Post 2084029)
Yes, many here go overboard sometimes, me included I'm afraid.

I'm glad you said it before I did. Get nice like me.


<---role model

Optimus Prime 08-24-2011 03:46 AM

Can we talk about the REAL golden rule?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pi7gwX7rjOw

AlphaFrog 08-24-2011 05:54 AM

This thread is sooooo 2007....Actually, we get one of these EVERY year, it's just that this particular one I remember who started and could easily find.


What this thread is lacking, however, is the OP telling us how many PMs she got in support of her thread. That's a classic rule of these kind of threads that can't be ignored.

shirley1929 08-24-2011 07:30 AM

I started this really in response to Wary's thread, so this either applies to you directly or it doesn't. Yes, she was warned not to continue, and she went forward, but does that give someone the license to create a sockpuppet with direct threats on her daughter's rush? Like they're the police of GreekChat?

Quote:

Originally Posted by AlphaFrog (Post 2084186)
What this thread is lacking, however, is the OP telling us how many PMs she got in support of her thread. That's a classic rule of these kind of threads that can't be ignored.

And, I actually know better than to do that, because I know I'd get further flamed. But since you mentioned it, yes, I have received several. :D

I seriously didn't think that just a reminder to play nice in the sandbox would get people THAT rankled. If you're being nice, (and most of you are or else I wouldn't be trying to salvage this place) then I'm not talking to you directly. What I guess I didn't think through so much, was that if you're not, then you probably won't listen to me anyway.

I've just had so many people say to me (noobs) that they're scared to post anything because they're afraid of saying something. Is that the kind of environment we want to be a part of?

AlphaFrog 08-24-2011 07:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084192)
I started this really in response to Wary's thread, so this either applies to you directly or it doesn't. Yes, she was warned not to continue, and she went forward, but does that give someone the license to create a sockpuppet with direct threats on her daughter's rush? Like they're the SS of GreekChat?



And, I actually know better than to do that, because I know I'd get further flamed. But since you mentioned it, yes, I have received several. :D

I seriously didn't think that just a reminder to play nice in the sandbox would get people THAT rankled. If you're being nice, (and most of you are or else I wouldn't be trying to salvage this place) then I'm not talking to you directly. What I guess I didn't think through so much, was that if you're not, then you probably won't listen to me anyway.

I've just had so many people say to me (noobs) that they're scared to post anything because they're afraid of saying something. Is that the kind of environment we want to be a part of?

SALVAGE this place? I wasn't aware that we were in need of a redeemer here. Should we praise you for offering yourself on the cross of ridicule? Sheesh.

shirley1929 08-24-2011 07:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AlphaFrog (Post 2084197)
SALVAGE this place? I wasn't aware that we were in need of a redeemer here. Should we praise you for offering yourself on the cross of ridicule? Sheesh.

Salvage is a big word, you're right & I haven't had coffee yet. :) Guess I meant salvage it for the noobs. I've just directed a bunch of people here for advice and they're literally scared of it and won't post any questions. Most of you (absolutely you AF) are wonderful lovely people. I'm just looking for more people to feel comfortable and quit lurking. Maybe I poop rainbows.

Drolefille 08-24-2011 08:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084192)

I've just had so many people say to me (noobs) that they're scared to post anything because they're afraid of saying something. Is that the kind of environment we want to be a part of?

Oh look, we got the PMs line now.

Boring.

Stop saying "we" like you represent anything but you.


Also since you fucking Godwin'd the thread you officially lose and the thread is over.

SS of Greekchat indeed, fuck you.

shirley1929 08-24-2011 08:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Drolefille (Post 2084204)
Oh look, we got the PMs line now.

Boring.

Stop saying "we" like you represent anything but you.


Also since you fucking Godwin'd the thread you officially lose and the thread is over.

SS of Greekchat indeed, fuck you.

Wow...hostility! Definitely wasn't looking for that, but OK.

If you read the next one, I'm talking about people I personally direct here (for the good info) and then become scared to ask anything.

G'Day.

Drolefille 08-24-2011 08:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084206)
Wow...hostility! Definitely wasn't looking for that, but OK.

If you read the next one, I'm talking about people I personally direct here (for the good info) and then become scared to ask anything.

G'Day.

So you didn't read my other posts in this thread then, I assume?

Again you make a lot of assumptions, including that I didn't read your posts. Stop doing that.

Also, when you make comparisons that are offensive, like piggybacking on the tragedy of teen suicides to tell us to ~behave~ ourselves, or making a fucking HOLOCAUST reference and comparing GC sockpuppets to the Nazi Schutzstaffel you're being fucking ignorant. Stop it.

Until GCers go to people's homes in the middle of the night and throw them into concentration camps that will never be an acceptable comparison.

shirley1929 08-24-2011 08:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Drolefille (Post 2084207)
Also, when you make comparisons that are offensive, like piggybacking on the tragedy of teen suicides to tell us to ~behave~ ourselves, or making a fucking HOLOCAUST reference and comparing GC sockpuppets to the Nazi Schutzstaffel you're being fucking ignorant. Stop it.

Until GCers go to people's homes in the middle of the night and throw them into concentration camps that will never be an acceptable comparison.

You know what? You're right. I apologize and will delete that part. BUT, it is reminscent of McCarthyism (better analogy?) when people become crazy stalkers and start "taking care" of things.

I guess it's probably not fun for you when I can have a calm conversation and admit when I'm wrong. I don't need to resort to profanity.

Many people don't do that here. I'm sincerely not trying to bash...I'm trying to help. Sorry that it's not coming off that way.

amIblue? 08-24-2011 08:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Drolefille (Post 2084207)

Until GCers go to people's homes in the middle of the night and throw them into concentration camps that will never be an acceptable comparison.


Absolutely.

But now I have this mental picture of the GC SS, which made me spit my coffee all over my laptop.

AlphaFrog 08-24-2011 08:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by amIblue? (Post 2084209)
Absolutely.

But now I have this mental picture of the GC SS, which made me spit my coffee all over my laptop.

Stop talking about us...uh, them....yeah, THEM like they exist. THEY DO NOT EXIST. Excuse me, I have some things, none of which are the least bit secret, to take care of.

Senusret I 08-24-2011 08:44 AM

But you bitches have been in rare form this August. I'm with shirley, come what may.

DrPhil 08-24-2011 08:46 AM

Threads like this always become ironic.

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084192)
I started this really in response to Wary's thread, so this either applies to you directly or it doesn't.

You created this "be nice" thread specifically in response to sock puppets and trolls? Womp womp.

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084192)
Yes, she was warned not to continue, and she went forward....

This should actually be the lesson. Everyone should already know that crazy readers, sock puppets, and trolls don't care about what they have a license to do. If being edited and banned mattered they would not come here in the first place.

People can continue to do whatever they do and put the onus on the crazy readers, sock puppets, and trolls. If that sounds smart to people then good luck to them.


Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084192)
And, I actually know better than to do that, because I know I'd get further flamed.

Where was the first flame? I wish people would stop making comments and then verbally preparing for some kind of backlash. You did that in your OP and you keep doing that. Own up to what you want to say and stop labeling the responses to your posts as flames. People...are...responding...to...you. If you don't want responses to your posts keep your opinions to yourself or private message them to someone who you know agrees with your every word.


Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084192)
I seriously didn't think that just a reminder to play nice in the sandbox would get people THAT rankled. If you're being nice, (and most of you are or else I wouldn't be trying to salvage this place) then I'm not talking to you directly. What I guess I didn't think through so much, was that if you're not, then you probably won't listen to me anyway.

I refuse to believe that you are clueless enough to create a thread to preach to sock puppets and trolls. How about you let us know who the nice and not nice usernames are. That will definitely rank and file usernames so that we can sing kumbaya one day.

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084192)
I've just had so many people say to me (noobs) that they're scared to post anything because they're afraid of saying something. Is that the kind of environment we want to be a part of?

We aren't going to change. Is that the kind of environment YOU want to be a part of?

DrPhil 08-24-2011 08:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084208)
BUT, it is reminscent of McCarthyism (better analogy?) when people become crazy stalkers and start "taking care" of things.

Please not this comparison again. Being dramatic in response to perceived drama never works. Find your own way to express your own opinion. Don't make yourself a spokesperson.

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084208)
I guess it's probably not fun for you when I can have a calm conversation and admit when I'm wrong. I don't need to resort to profanity.

Many people don't do that here. I'm sincerely not trying to bash...I'm trying to help. Sorry that it's not coming off that way.

Life lesson:
I consider your tone condescending and it makes you that which you despise. Announcing that you are calm and that you are trying to help can receive a negative response on GC and in real life depending on the topic and who you're talking to.

SWTXBelle 08-24-2011 09:04 AM

In before the lock.

eta - Those who come to GC for information will find many stickies which cover most topics. Those who post honest questions in a spirit of friendship will receive support and answers. Those who post with a sense of entitlement, or self-importance, will not. It's a classic example of you get what you give. Things don't just turn snarky - there is a flashpoint.

als463 08-24-2011 10:18 AM

I have to admit, I can't believe this thread has gone on for so long....wow.

shirley, I have something to add. You talked about how someone (I'm assuming from Texas or who has a chapter of their organization at Texas) was able to pick this young woman out in the crowd during recruitment. Here's my question: Doesn't that concern you on the part of the mother's lack of discretion, in the least? I have no clue who you are talking about or what really happened---you aren't telling us everything---but, if a PNM is that discernable from the rest of the crowd (UT has TONS of PNMs going through), then that's a problem.

Sure, there are crazy people who lurk, sock-puppet, troll, etc. The truth is that you never know who is on here. As Drolefille stated earlier, many of us have people from our Inter/National headquarters on here (though they may not post). I'm sorry to hear about that young woman's recruitment not working out for her but, maybe you should be pointing the finger at mom who gave away so much information that she was easy to spot. If anything, that is a potentially dangerous situation that you are giving up so much information about your child or loved one that strangers on a website can pick them out of a line-up.

So, stop yelling at those of us on GC that don't go looking to ruin someone's recruitment. Instead, start looking at the poor behavior of some of the parents who feel the need to disclose so many details about their child on an internet forum.

DrPhil 08-24-2011 10:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by als463 (Post 2084239)
I have to admit, I can't believe this thread has gone on for so long....wow.

I stumbled upon this thread last night and discovered that I was indeed summoned. :)

als463 08-24-2011 10:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrPhil (Post 2084242)
I stumbled upon this thread last night and discovered that I was indeed summoned. :)

Oh yes, this is true. I have to thank you, DF, MC, and KS (even though he didn't really say much) for adding to this thread. I also like that Alpha Frog shared.

DrPhil 08-24-2011 10:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by als463 (Post 2084244)
Oh yes, this is true. I have to thank you, DF, MC, and KS (even though he didn't really say much) for adding to this thread. I also like that Alpha Frog shared.

Stop using us for your amusement! :mad: :p

AOII Angel 08-24-2011 10:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by als463 (Post 2084239)
I have to admit, I can't believe this thread has gone on for so long....wow.

shirley, I have something to add. You talked about how someone (I'm assuming from Texas or who has a chapter of their organization at Texas) was able to pick this young woman out in the crowd during recruitment. Here's my question: Doesn't that concern you on the part of the mother's lack of discretion, in the least? I have no clue who you are talking about or what really happened---you aren't telling us everything---but, if a PNM is that discernable from the rest of the crowd (UT has TONS of PNMs going through), then that's a problem.

Sure, there are crazy people who lurk, sock-puppet, troll, etc. The truth is that you never know who is on here. As Drolefille stated earlier, many of us have people from our Inter/National headquarters on here (though they may not post). I'm sorry to hear about that young woman's recruitment not working out for her but, maybe you should be pointing the finger at mom who gave away so much information that she was easy to spot. If anything, that is a potentially dangerous situation that you are giving up so much information about your child or loved one that strangers on a website can pick them out of a line-up.

So, stop yelling at those of us on GC that don't go looking to ruin someone's recruitment. Instead, start looking at the poor behavior of some of the parents who feel the need to disclose so many details about their child on an internet forum.

Well said. The psycho troll who did this was cruel, but they needed help to find their victim. Don't feed the troll.

amIblue? 08-24-2011 11:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AlphaFrog (Post 2084210)
Stop talking about us...uh, them....yeah, THEM like they exist. THEY DO NOT EXIST. Excuse me, I have some things, none of which are the least bit secret, to take care of.

Now, I've got different GC SS regiments going through my head. Different colored shirts for different sororities - (i.e., the Kappas would be known as the Blueshirts).

Also, are the PNMs on GC considered the GC Youth? Preparing for the day when they can join their regiment.

I mean, if we're going to go with the Nazi comparisons, let's do it right. :p

DGTess 08-24-2011 11:28 AM

Quote:

People get bashed for withdrawing BEFORE PREF while in the same breath bitching about being dropped by the popular chapters.
I have never seen a rushee claim she dropped because she was dropped by the popular chapters.

Now, I haven't read every thread, so I could have missed one or three, but most often she claims she didn't feel a connection with the chapters she ranked low, and GC women to whom she comes for advice make the value judgements.

Okay, I get that you believe it's your right.

Bless your heart.

shirley1929 08-24-2011 11:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrPhil (Post 2084214)
Life lesson:
I consider your tone condescending and it makes you that which you despise. Announcing that you are calm and that you are trying to help can receive a negative response on GC and in real life depending on the topic and who you're talking to.

And maybe that's what the very crux of my point is. Given that it's the written word, tone is VERY subjective. I didn't mean to be condescending, and yet I came off that way to you. You (the collective you of course) can come off that way as well, so we should all just be a little more careful in wording I guess.

Quote:

Originally Posted by als463 (Post 2084239)
I have to admit, I can't believe this thread has gone on for so long....wow.

Agree. I thought it would be one post and done, but apparently a struck a nerve somewhere?

Quote:

Originally Posted by als463 (Post 2084239)
shirley, I have something to add. You talked about how someone (I'm assuming from Texas or who has a chapter of their organization at Texas) was able to pick this young woman out in the crowd during recruitment. Here's my question: Doesn't that concern you on the part of the mother's lack of discretion, in the least? I have no clue who you are talking about or what really happened---you aren't telling us everything---but, if a PNM is that discernable from the rest of the crowd (UT has TONS of PNMs going through), then that's a problem.

I actually wasn't the one talking about this, I just mentioned that thread in general. I haven't said anything (to my memory) in that thread, I just referenced it. And yes, it does concern me (as I believe I mentioned in here) that the poster didn't listen, but do I think she then deserves what she got? NO.

Quote:

Originally Posted by als463 (Post 2084239)
Sure, there are crazy people who lurk, sock-puppet, troll, etc. The truth is that you never know who is on here. As Drolefille stated earlier, many of us have people from our Inter/National headquarters on here (though they may not post). I'm sorry to hear about that young woman's recruitment not working out for her but, maybe you should be pointing the finger at mom who gave away so much information that she was easy to spot. If anything, that is a potentially dangerous situation that you are giving up so much information about your child or loved one that strangers on a website can pick them out of a line-up.

So, you are saying she got what she deserved? I'm still really baffled at that.

Quote:

Originally Posted by als463 (Post 2084239)
So, stop yelling at those of us on GC that don't go looking to ruin someone's recruitment. Instead, start looking at the poor behavior of some of the parents who feel the need to disclose so many details about their child on an internet forum.

Seriously...where did I yell? Did I call you by name? If it doesn't apply to you, then don't respond to it. Simple. For the tenth time, I'm just asking people to think about how they can be construed before they post.

knight_shadow 08-24-2011 12:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084284)
Agree. I thought it would be one post and done, but apparently a struck a nerve somewhere?

No, you didn't:
Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2083805)
I’m also not stupid enough to believe that I’m not about to get flamed right now.

---

I’m sure there’s more – I’ll be back.

Let the bashing begin in…5…4…3…

Quote:

If it doesn't apply to you, then don't respond to it. Simple.
You should take your own advice. It's really not that serious.

SWTXBelle 08-24-2011 12:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by amIblue? (Post 2084272)
Now, I've got different GC SS regiments going through my head. Different colored shirts for different sororities - (i.e., the Kappas would be known as the Blueshirts).

Also, are the PNMs on GC considered the GC Youth? Preparing for the day when they can join their regiment.

I mean, if we're going to go with the Nazi comparisons, let's do it right. :p


Ummm . . . so what would the Gamma Phis be known as? :eek:

amIblue? 08-24-2011 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SWTXBelle (Post 2084290)
Ummm . . . so what would the Gamma Phis be known as? :eek:

Brownshirts is probably a tad much, don't you think? Perhaps the modeshirts? But I don't want to be a shirt color Nazi, so I'll leave it up to you awesome Gamma Phis! :D

ASTalumna06 08-24-2011 12:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084284)
And maybe that's what the very crux of my point is. Given that it's the written word, tone is VERY subjective. I didn't mean to be condescending, and yet I came off that way to you. You (the collective you of course) can come off that way as well, so we should all just be a little more careful in wording I guess.

But when that happens to us, we explain ourselves, say sorry and move on. We don't preach to everyone that they all need to be nicer. We're typing on a message board.. misunderstandings happen. Get over it.


Quote:

I actually wasn't the one talking about this, I just mentioned that thread in general. I haven't said anything (to my memory) in that thread, I just referenced it. And yes, it does concern me (as I believe I mentioned in here) that the poster didn't listen, but do I think she then deserves what she got? NO.

So, you are saying she got what she deserved? I'm still really baffled at that.
Look, you screw up, you pay the consequences. The end.

shirley1929 08-24-2011 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ASTalumna06 (Post 2084296)
But when that happens to us, we explain ourselves, say sorry and move on. We don't preach to everyone that they all need to be nicer. We're typing on a message board.. misunderstandings happen. Get over it.

And sometimes you (the collective you, of course) aren't given the opportunity to apologize. The noob just slithers off because they're scared of your tone.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ASTalumna06 (Post 2084296)
Look, you screw up, you pay the consequences. The end.

Not gonna lie...that sounded hella creepy to me. So, some poor girl who did absolutely NOTHING wrong except having a mom who is overzealous and shares a little too much has to "pay the consequences"? And you're justifying it?

aopirose 08-24-2011 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by als463 (Post 2084244)
Oh yes, this is true. I have to thank you, DF, MC, and KS (even though he didn't really say much) for adding to this thread. I also like that Alpha Frog shared.

I am hurt that I wasn't included. :( I think that it is important for people to know that Orange Julius is still around. "Go Orange Julius!" :D

knight_shadow 08-24-2011 12:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084300)
Not gonna lie...that sounded hella creepy to me. So, some poor girl who did absolutely NOTHING wrong except having a mom who is overzealous and shares a little too much has to "pay the consequences"? And you're justifying it?

Actions having consequences is "creepy" to you?

LOL @ what this thread has become

shirley1929 08-24-2011 01:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by knight_shadow (Post 2084302)
Actions having consequences is "creepy" to you?

LOL @ what this thread has become

No, it was the tone with which she said it. :D :rolleyes:

And that it was justified that the "consequences" were to the innocent daughter, not the mother. That's what creeps me out.

ASTalumna06 08-24-2011 01:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084300)
And sometimes you (the collective you, of course) aren't given the opportunity to apologize. The noob just slithers off because they're scared of your tone.



Not gonna lie...that sounded hella creepy to me. So, some poor girl who did absolutely NOTHING wrong except having a mom who is overzealous and shares a little too much has to "pay the consequences"? And you're justifying it?

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084304)
No, it was the tone with which she said it. :D :rolleyes:

And that it was justified that the "consequences" were to the innocent daughter, not the mother. That's what creeps me out.

Oh my.. It's true.. You really do live in Happy Pony Rainbow Land, huh?

Look, if I'm holding your hand and you decide to jump off a cliff, I pay for your stupid decision. I never said the daughter deserves to have all of her hopes and dreams crushed! I simply said that if you do something stupid, you can't be surprised when shit hits the fan. And you definitely can't blame us nice GCers, who only tried to help the mother out by telling her to shut up.

Does it suck that she ruined her daughter's shot at getting into a sorority? Yes. Should she be surprised at the outcome of her decision to not keep her mouth shut? No. Like I said a little ways back.. We tell the truth, and people don't want to hear it. Too bad.


ETA: p.s. how is that opinion "creepy"? It's not like I said I think it'd be a good idea to stare in your bedroom window all night..

DrPhil 08-24-2011 01:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084284)
And maybe that's what the very crux of my point is. Given that it's the written word, tone is VERY subjective. I didn't mean to be condescending, and yet I came off that way to you. You (the collective you of course) can come off that way as well, so we should all just be a little more careful in wording I guess.

Was that your only point in creating this thread? LOL.

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084300)
And sometimes you (the collective you, of course) aren't given the opportunity to apologize. The noob just slithers off because they're scared of your tone.

Boohoo to the noob who slithers off? Good gracious. LOL.

Quote:

Originally Posted by shirley1929 (Post 2084284)
Not gonna lie...that sounded hella creepy to me. So, some poor girl who did absolutely NOTHING wrong except having a mom who is overzealous and shares a little too much has to "pay the consequences"? And you're justifying it?

Do you seriously think she is justifying what happened? I think you don't really know which battle you're fighting. There are a few battles here, some of which are exaggerated.

DrPhil 08-24-2011 01:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by knight_shadow (Post 2084302)
LOL @ what this thread has become

LOL. Since when have usernames been able to create preachy threads with no responses? The OP should've replied in the Wary thread and been done with it. LOL.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:48 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.