OK, I had to bring this back up to the top. I don't know if the show is going to shake our country up, but are you still watching? Do you care who wins? If not, is it because you're watching people advance to the finals who shouldn't be there?

In the meantime, last night's show was the best! I didn't want to see Randy fight Simon, but I'm glad they finally bucked up and told Simon that he is entirely too cruel. He actually made a girl cry last night. She didn't give her best performance, but it wasn't that bad. Actually, only 2 or 3 performers were excellent last night. I'm looking forward to the finals.

Oh yeah....I'm hooked. I gotta tape it b/c I get off work at 10 pm.

I agree with you about the quality of yesterday's singers... but, I didn't believe the Simon vs. the other Judges thing for a minute!! It looked more fake than the Jerry Springer show. I think it was just a ploy to boost ratings.

~RHOyal #1

If that was the case,...
 

They got fooled your girl. Frankly, Simon is cruel, but he's so honest and truthful! Tonight seemed a little staged also, especially when they concentrated so hard on it before revealing the next finalists. I admire his honesty unlike Paula Abdul's frequent sugar-coating.