Sciencewoman |
09-21-2014 04:39 PM |
I've thought about this issue quite a bit over the years, because there is such a disparity between campus norms in the area of recs. It seems to me we have these scenarios:
1. Competitive campuses where PNMs need recs because they are the campus norm, regardless of each group's inter/national policy, and to not have them would be detrimental to continuing. They are a PNM's "stamp of approval" (exceptions made for Miss Teen USA, Olympic figure skaters, and other extremely rare snowflakes, in which case groups who require a rec per inter/national policy will find a willing aluma to write one, and other groups may well invite her back without one, and they won't need to have anyone ever fill one out behind the scenes).
2. Competitive campuses where some/many savvy PNMs may have recs, but it generally isn't a kiss of death is they don't; they are more useful as a "heads up" to the groups, and may give a PNM an advantage. Again, those groups who require one will get one, at some stage, via some means unknown to non-members.
3. Campuses where recs are rarely seen, PNMs are allowed to sign up for recruitment until almost the last minute, campuses where there there are high numbers of international students who likely have no sorority connections (I'm thinking about the MIT recruitment story I wrote this fall), etc. Recs are not the campus norm, but it sounds like groups who require them would still find an alumna to complete a rec??
I think an underlying question is: In the case of required recs at the inter/national level, is the rec's purpose primarily for membership selection, or is it more of an endorsement for membership by an alum (perhaps after the collegians have determined the PNM is someone they want). It's up to each sorority to privately discuss and determine how recs are used. I'd argue that there doesn't seem to be much validity in a rec done behind the scenes by an alumna who doesn't know the PNM.
Women who are most familiar with Scenario 1 recruitments seem to have a hard time believing that Scenarios 2 and 3 exist, and that no one is secretly securing recs behind the scenes for all of these rec-less women. After reading these posts over the years, I think I have determined a couple of NPC groups that do require a rec form for every PNM before she is extended a bid, but I think there are many more groups who don't, and lots of PNMs in Scenario 2 and 3 don't have them...ever.
|