That still doesn't make their discipline her business.

If she decides to stop paying, that doesn't necessarily mean the daugher needs to stop pledging.

And no, it's still none of her business.

FWIW, mom asked if the sorority could de-pledge the OTHER girls.

Which, again, is none of her business - no matter who is paying.

Groups of people tend do their own self-policing (much like kids in a school yard when "the whole class" gets in trouble) for something one or a few people did.

Read between the lines.

I meant daughter has no say about her mom paying, not whether she can find a way to finance herself. She can do whatever she wants to raise the money herself.

I'm surprised that you guys seem so offended by the asking to de-pledge other girls. Obviously she can't do that, so I don't see why anyone would be bothered by that. Besides, I think it's obvious that she's overall more concerned about her daughter's happiness rather than the other pledges. I think it's ridiculous if you think that daughter's happiness is not the root of all of this. Her daughter is her business.

Splash, perhaps you missed this earlier comment of mine.

Well maybe her daughter needs to take the stick out of her ass.

Seriously, if she's going to whine to mom every time someone has a party without her she's going to have a really miserable life.

I think it's a matter of "my daughter shouldn't be punished for something that someone else did".

It happens all the time. In elementary school, someone throws a spitball, but the whole class gets in trouble. On sports teams, someone screws up a play, and the whole team has to do laps. In high school, three people steal a copy of the test and the entire class has to re-take it. You work in a restaurant where you pool tips (all tips are collected and divided), and one sucky worker who gets rotten tips ends up reducing each person's portion.

It happens everywhere. There's a reason and a purpose. Can you - Splash or OP - not see that?

How the sorority operates is none of her business. Asking online whether the chapter can de-pledge the troublemakers is NONE OF HER BUSINESS. Furthermore, her daughter is an adult and should be making these decisions on her own. Meaning, it's NONE OF HER BUSINESS! I don't understand why you keep insisting that it is.

First, to the OP, this truly is something your daughter needs to handle since there really isn't anything you as her mother can do about it. I would suggest that she and her group of friends request a meeting with the president or standards officer and take it from there.

As to paying for it=privy to it...my parents paid for my membership, but my mother never asked for information on internal affairs (probably because she is Greek and knows better). I believe they have a right to know what they're paying for and would have been glad to show my parents the breakdown of dues and where the money went. But that's it.

A dry pledgeship is hazing unless every sister, both new member and active, is held to those standards and somehow I doubt they are unless it is something required by nationals. However something my mother told me before I joined was that sororities do have some amount of control over your life. You can be sanctioned or expelled for bad/illegal behavior. If Active Amy is drinking underage at her apartment with one other sister who isn't going to tell on her and Nancy New Member is underage, dancing on stage at the bar with a beer in hand, it's going to be Nancy who finds herself in trouble. Fair or not. Discretion is key.

That doesn't make it right. No one said life is fair, but I do not believe in treating an entire group badly for the mistakes of one or two members. I would have had a problem with it as a new member were I in this girl's situation. On the other hand, I would have gotten a few girls who agreed with me and gone to an officer to talk about my concerns.

I totally agree that it doesn't make it right, but that's how life is. Right now, I'm in medical school and when one student in our class screws up (not preparing for case studies, leaving the lab messy, etc.) our entire class pays for one person's mistake.

It isn't ideal nor is it "right" but it's how the "real world" is.

I do agree that musicmom's daughter has every reason to be irritated if she really is innocent. I am sure, however, she simply complained to her mom in passing and didn't expect her to actually attempt to DO anything about it.

After all, I have complained to my mother, just in conversation, about things both in my chapter and currently, in medical school. I would have been beyond mortified if my mother had decided to take those simple pieces of conversation and post them on a message board for all the world to see.

I just don't see anything wrong with her and her friends who are innocent attempting to talk to the powers that be in the chapter. It might be how the "real world" works and yes, sororities are definitely supposed to help you prepare for that, but it is a sisterhood.

Agree that it would be very inconvenient for me had my mother talked piblically about all the things I coplained to her about in the years I was an active. She was my sounding board when I was frustrated since she is Greek and could offer objective advice (one example: Stop sweating the small stuff and remember this is a group of 18-22 year old women. They WILL behave childishly at times, and so will you. That was a good thing to remember.)

There is not enough information here to judge what's going on in the chapter. (Is it hazing or not? Is the 'punishment' appropriate reactions to Risk Management issues or not?) But that's ok since it's none of the mom's business anyway.

Either pay for dues with the conditions up front* or don't pay them at all.

*Reasonable conditions include keeping grades up, not getting in trouble with campus security/police/whatever, and so on.

This, plus "and I want to know what can be done about it, because I think they should depledge the troublemakers."

Parents can be great emotional outlets, but I think it goes too far when they try to handle things with their adult children.

All I have to say is: daughter needs to handle it herself by seeking advice from the appropriate people, which may include her pledge class, sorority's president, pledge educator, or even Greek Life advisor!

This is true. But it is her doing it in public that makes her a target for discipline, not her new member status.

I would like to know what "partying" entails as nebbymom wrote in her original post. If that's all it is - a faction of the pledge class sitting around someone's apartment and having a beer - or even a faction of girls going out to a party together - IMO the pledge trainer is way out of line for bitching at them to begin with. Is it rude to divide up like that? Yes. Does it happen all the time (especially at a school w/ ginormous pledge classes)? Yes.

In answer to OPs question, yes, new members can be depledged if they are a risk to the chapter. However, and this is what everyone has been going on about, we can't say if that is the appropriate measure in this case. Your daughter could be making a mountain out of a mole hill, or the chapter could be in free-fall, or one of a thousand points in between. As a college woman and a new sorority member, this is a good time for her to learn how to deal with political infighting and awkward situations herself.

I would continue to be a shoulder for your daughter, but do stay out of it and don't tell your daughter what to do about it. You could end up getting your foot in it and causing her and yourself a great deal of trouble.

But I can tell you with confidence that if the new members are partying so hard that it is causing a disruption to the chapter, their grades will suffer and the problem with resolve itself. And that's probably what the chapter is doing - waiting for the problem to resolve itself.