My all time favorite was Chocolate Amber but it was only out for a very short time and they discontinued it. Seeing this thread reminded me that I wanted to email them about it. So I emailed them this afternoon and they responded that they have no intention of bringing it back. They suggested I try Sensual Amber, which I do use all the time, but Chocolate Amber was so much better.

The Blue Spa body lotion with minoi oil (used to be called "Tahiti Sweetie") is the best!

Eucalyptus Spearmint aroma therapy & Eucalyptus Mint, which are exactly the same thing, despite what the employees at BBW say.

I still miss Sparkling Peach, but it's long gone now.

I wear this lotion on my hands most everyday.

I remember cucumber melon being all the rage back in the day. I haven't been to a B&Bw in a long time so I wonder if it's even still available.

I think it's gone from BBW but the Body Fantasies version is just as good if not better, IMO.

I love the Shea Cashmere lotion and body butter - those are the only B&BW lotions that don't feel sticky to me.

I used to really like the Iced Pineapple and Frozen Daiquiri scents, but of course they discontinued them years ago. There's a limoncello Wallflower plug-in right now that I really like.

My favorite scent is Sea Island Cotton. I have enough of it to stock a small store. I have promised myself that I will not buy anymore until I have used (or almost used) all of what I already have.