Actually, I'd say it's more who was in the house before her.

Out of my graduating class, I think like 20 of us went there.....a lot of people's older brothers and sisters are at Madison. This could work for or against her....in this case she found the house with ppl's older sisters who are family friends and willing to baby her. Kind of sad, although her name is pretty much recognizable wherever she goes so I'd consider that punishment too.

I think Mr. and Mrs. Holz did their daughter, and the community, a huge disservice by trying to help Marnie avoid the consequences for her hazing participation. At the same time, she was not one of the participants who received criminal charges. She was in the wrong place at the wrong time and her name is known to the world because of her parents' bad judgement.

While I can certainly understand groups of women not wanting an overindulged baby as part of their sisterhood, I also think that Marnie deserves to be able to put her and her parents' mistakes behind her and get on with the rest of her life. I guess the only thing I'd worry about is whether the house that gave her a bid thought what happened in Northbrook was no big deal; that sure isn't anyplace I'd want my daughter to be!

I hope Marnie's learned some humility in the process, she sure didn't find any public support for her legal battle. She missed prom, she missed graduation; those consequences fit the crime, and for an 18-year-old were pretty severe. Everything happens for a reason, maybe Marnie's going to learn something from her new sisters that her parents were incapable of teaching her at home.

Guilty Verdict
 

The first hazing case to go to trial resulted in a guilty verdict. The mom who hosted the party goes on trial Thursday.

Teen guilty in Glenbrook hazing
Former senior sentenced to year of court supervision in battery case

By Courtney Flynn
Tribune staff reporter
Published November 4, 2003

Despite testimony from a former Glenbrook North High School senior who maintained her innocence in a violent hazing, a judge found her guilty Monday of misdemeanor battery.

After a bench trial that lasted about 15 minutes in the Skokie courthouse, Cook County Circuit Judge Timothy Chambers sentenced Gina Mengarelli, 18, of the 2600 block of Cherry Lane in Northbrook to a year of court supervision.




"As foolish as the activities of the defendant may have been, I do not think they were criminal," said Mengarelli's attorney, Steven Decker, who plans to appeal.

Mengarelli's case was the first stemming from the widely publicized hazing to go to trial.

Fourteen other teens have been found guilty of misdemeanor battery or alcohol charges related to the hazing, which occurred May 4 in Chipilly Woods, near Northbrook. One parent has pleaded guilty to providing alcohol to minors.

A second parent is expected to appear in court Thursday on charges she provided a place for minors to drink. Another former student awaits trial in December.

During her trial Monday, Mengarelli admitted she threw ketchup, mustard and coffee grounds at junior girls during the fracas.

Mengarelli, who now attends an out-of-state college, repeatedly denied striking one junior in the back with her knee and pulling another girl's hair and pushing her to the ground, as prosecutors alleged.

Asked by her attorney if she intended to harm any of the juniors, Mengarelli responded: "Absolutely not."

Mengarelli told the judge she believed the juniors consented to her actions because they freely participated in the event.


Copyright © 2003, Chicago Tribune

Mom is Guilty!
 

Does Mrs. Spiwak get it yet? Her lawyer, Gal Pissetzky, said: "She never bought any beer. She never provided the beer. She never said, `Drink the beer.'" Oh, but providing your deck for the party is okay?

Here's the story...

Mother found guilty in hazing
Woman allowed teens to drink before melee

By Lisa Black
Tribune staff reporter
Published November 14, 2003

A woman was found guilty Thursday of allowing Glenbrook North High School students to drink beer in her Northbrook home in the hours before the teenagers participated in a violent hazing in a forest preserve.

Marcy Spiwak, 50, was impassive as Judge Timothy Chambers sentenced her to one year of court supervision and 40 hours of community service.

The consequences for Spiwak should send a strong message to other parents, said Cook County Assistant State's Atty. Steve Goebel.

"Parents do need to realize they can't simply provide alcohol to minors," Goebel said at the Skokie courthouse after Spiwak was sentenced. "These girls drank at the house and went out and got battered."

Spiwak was found guilty of permitting a violation of the Illinois Liquor Control Act, a misdemeanor.

During the hazing May 4, senior girls were videotaped kicking, punching and throwing objects at junior girls in a muddy field at Chipilly Woods in Northbrook.

Before the melee, 20 to 30 of the students drank beer from a keg on Spiwak's back deck in the 3700 block of Whirlaway Drive, Goebel said. The juniors included Spiwak's daughter, her friends and some of their boyfriends, Goebel said. Spiwak's daughter was not charged.

After the hazing, five juniors were treated at a hospital. One girl needed 10 stitches to her head. Others suffered bruises and concussions. A few of those who were hurt had been drinking at Spiwak's house before the hazing, officials said.

In September, another parent, Christine Neal, 49, of Northbrook, pleaded guilty to providing the alcohol, which included two kegs of beer that were delivered to the forest preserve. Neal was sentenced to one year of probation and 14 days of community service.

On Thursday, Spiwak said that she would like to talk. But she angrily added, "I've read too many lies about myself," and declined to comment further.

Her lawyer, Gal Pissetzky, said: "She never bought any beer. She never provided the beer. She never said, `Drink the beer.'"

Besides the parents, 15 of 16 teenagers charged with battery or alcohol-related offenses related to the hazing have been found guilty.

Only one former Glenbrook North senior, Eliran Maman, awaits a court date Dec. 1. Maman, 18, of Glenview, is charged with battery.

Northfield Township High School District 225 expelled 33 seniors and disciplined 20 juniors after the hazing.

Before she was arrested, Spiwak said in an interview that her older daughter participated in the annual hazing six years ago without any violence.

"They also had kegs of beer," Spiwak said in May. "Nobody was hurt. What they used was ketchup, mustard, eggs and flour. There was no violence. I don't even feel the alcohol is part of this."

Prosecutors disagreed.

"Anyone who looked at the tapes can see that alcohol fueled part of the frenzy that went on," Goebel said Thursday.

"Some of the junior girls were drunk, and senior girls were drunk."

Goebel said police officers have told him that, after publicity about the hazing, fewer parents have been cited for allowing minors to drink in their homes.

"I think parents got the message," he said.

The End
 

The last of the kids charged in the GBN hazing incident pleaded guilty yesterday. This kid's supervision won't be able to be expunged from his record, unlike all the other kids involved. This kid has been in trouble before.

There are still some loose ends--how will the school board react to the recommendations of the hazing task force, for example. We got a new handbook in the mail a few weeks ago with the schools rights to react to things that happen off school grounds made much more clear. The schools seem to act more quickly to issues which could become newsworthy--for example, our club hockey team waved a confederate flag in the homecoming parade (we're South--get it???). Before school started the following Monday, the damage control had already started. The school sanctioned GBS powder puff game was canceled this year.

I'm still a little baffled about how this hazing thing happened for so long before someone finally spoke up. I guess I'll never really understand it. I feel like I live in a community that values its youth and that emphasizes Character. My kids friends are all really great kids: they're involved in the community and take their studies seriously. It's hard for me to imagine parents tolerating a tradition like this for so many years, much less assisting in its logistics.
>>>>
Last student sentenced in hazing
Glenbrook reviews task force ideas

By Lisa Black, Tribune staff reporter. Freelance reporter Sean D. Hamill contributed to this report
Published December 2, 2003

The last person facing criminal charges from a brutal hazing last spring involving Glenbrook North High School students pleaded guilty to battery Monday, the same day school board members discussed a task force's recommendations on how to prevent similar violence.

Former student Eliran Maman, 18, of the 3000 block of Lexington Lane, Glenview, admitted he had kicked a junior girl in the head, which was covered by a bucket, as she knelt on the ground during the May 4 melee in Chipilly Woods near Northbrook.

Cook County Circuit Judge Timothy Chambers sentenced Maman in the Skokie courthouse to a year of conditional discharge, a form of court supervision that cannot be expunged from his record.

Maman and his father declined to comment.

"He's glad it's over," said his attorney, Alan Davis. "Most of these kids are really good children who made a mistake and are being punished. The punishment was serious enough that they thought about what they did. Chances are you'll never see 99 percent of them in the legal system again."

Maman was the last of the 16 students found guilty in the hazing, in which seniors at the Northbrook school were videotaped beating juniors at a forest preserve.

Five girls were treated at a hospital; one required 10 stitches in her head, and others had bruises and concussions.

Northfield Township High School District 225 expelled 33 seniors and disciplined 20 juniors after the incident.

The hazing prompted school district and village administrators to form a task force to study how to prevent it from happening again. Organized in June, the group looked at broader teen issues, recommending a communitywide code of civility, additional police training and increased enforcement of current laws.

District 225 board members told administrators Monday night to review the task force's report and decide which portions the district should deal with.

"I think an awful lot of this is outside the purview of this district," said board member Robert Boron, who was on the task force. "Some issues [in the report] have already been addressed through some revised school policies."

Some recommendations in the report may be beyond the district's power because of jurisdictional issues, such as better monitoring of teenage activity in the forest preserves.

"Most of this goes back to the home," said board member Tom Shaer, adding that he did not want the school district "to go hard into an area that is not our responsibility."

Supt. David Hales said the task force suggested that the board decide which recommendations to adopt by mid-April, before the anniversary of the hazing.

The Northbrook Village Board will review the task force's report Dec. 9 and decide whether to push for new laws, officials said.

Most of the students found guilty in the hazing-related battery cases have gone to college and will be eligible to have their records expunged in a year.

Maman has completed 80 hours of community service and been evaluated for alcohol and substance abuse because of earlier charges unrelated to the hazing, Davis said.